Local news delivered daily to your email inbox. Subscribe for FREE to the rdnewsNOW newsletter.

Alberta applying for a judicial review of federal carbon price, calling it unfair

Oct 29, 2024 | 1:04 PM

EDMONTON — Premier Danielle Smith says Alberta has applied for a judicial review of Ottawa’s exemption of the carbon levy on home heating oil.

She says it’s “blatantly” unfair to Albertans who rely on natural gas to heat their homes and that relief can’t wait with cold winter weather coming.

Alberta Justice Minister Mickey Amery says it took about a year for the province to assemble its legal argument and he expects it to take another year to work its way through court.

Amery says providing a benefit to those who use heating oil, predominantly in Atlantic Canada, undermines what’s supposed to be a national standard.

Smith says the carbon levy is increasingly contributing to financial pain, but Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s Liberals say it puts money back into the pockets of Canadians in the form of rebates.

Smith says her United Conservative Party government is asking the court to declare the exemption both unconstitutional and unlawful in hopes of seeing the levy axed altogether.

Naheed Nenshi, Leader of Alberta’s New Democrats, issued the following statement in response:
“It’s very clear that the premier doesn’t think that Pierre Poilievre is going to win the next federal election if she is tying us up in court for so many years on yet another unwinnable court case.
“I’m no lawyer, but the Supreme Court has ruled that the carbon tax is constitutional. Certainly, the federal government really dropped the ball in creating the carve out for home heating oil. I don’t know why they thought that was a good idea. They absolutely undermined the consumer carbon tax in a very big way.
“But again, instead of making a deal with the federal government, instead of talking about an exemption for natural gas or even more rebate money going to people in Alberta who want to get off home heating oil, the UCP government just chooses to fight.
“The most telling part of the premier’s press conference today was when she was asked if she talked to the federal government and her response was, ‘Why would I do that?’
“This premier doesn’t want to win, she just wants to fight. So, she wants to drag out a court case for as many years as she can so she can show she is fighting.”
“Why would she time this pointless announcement on another fight with the federal government for today? Could it have anything to do with her leadership review on Saturday?”

This report by The Canadian Press was first published Oct. 29, 2024.

The Canadian Press

(With files from rdnewsNOW)